#16 David or David?

Donatello’s vs. Michelangelo’s David:

After reading about and viewing both artists depiction of David I have decided I prefer Michelangelo’s the most. His sculpture is preferable as it portrays David more as I would envision him. He is strong and youthful with the stone and sling in hand. In comparison, Donatello’s sculpture is more gruesome as it includes the head of Goliath, and is less impressive as far as the boy’s body goes. It is strange to me to see him in the nude, yet still be wearing a hat and boots.

In terms of how each reflects the Biblical story, Donatello’s David includes both the stone in the sling along with the head of goliath at his feet. This gives a short summary of the story through the art piece of before and after David defeats Goliath. During the time period this was created, the David was made in a style of power and force. It was also common at the time to portray heroes in the nude. Yet like the book says, “Donatello’s figures may be harsh, to the point of being disturbing, projecting greater drama and emotionalism than ever before seen in Italian sculpture.”

 On the other hand, Michelangelo’s David simply has the sling in one hand and the stone in the other. This portrays a scene of before the action, before David goes to fight, creating a more dramatic and suspenseful feel to the art. This David stands in the famous pose, ready for action yet still looking at ease. He is portrayed at this time as youthful through his large head and hands.

Both sculptures created pieces that would be viewed as strong and inspiring, telling of a young man who despite all odds was able to defeat the giant Goliath. These pieces are both great portrayals of their time periods and can teach us a lot. The religious influence is apparent as David’s strength and success came from the help and his trust in God.